The Spanish Melting Pot

When living in a place, I think it’s important to know something about it. I’ve been to countless museums, historical sites, and prehistorical archaeological sites in Spain. And while it’s been interesting, weaving it all together hasn’t always been easy. I needed a coach.

We aren’t taught much European history when we go through school in the US. Other than the fact that while so many of us have ancestors that hailed from Europe; in America, we wanted to do it our way. But connecting with the history of Spain became even more important to me after having my DNA done last year. I found out I have Iberian, Moroccan and Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry. Yep, this fair skinned, freckle faced, blue-eyed girl has all that. Plus some German, Scandinavian, Eastern European and, yes, Celtic – Scottish, Welsh, Irish DNA (which is what I had always been told I was, almost exclusively).

So, now that I have skin in the Spanish game, I needed to understand Spanish history. To get the ball moving forward, I took a 20 hour lecture series on Spanish history from a professor of anthropology who specializes in the history of the Iberian Peninsula. And in doing so, it’s changed my view of every thing I thought I knew about my own history.

I won’t bore you with all that I learned. I’m well aware that most people would find sitting through 20 hours of anthropological lectures a real snore fest. So I’m just that strange, getting super jazzed before another hour listening to all this rich history that came alive for me in the retelling. And it opened my eyes to not just myself, but how connected we all really are. Whether we want to admit it or not.

Spain has always been a cross-roads of cultures, religions and ideas. It’s position at the mouth of the Mediterranean pretty much ensured that. But it’s also a place with varied terrain and climates, perfect for raising livestock and prolific farming. It’s mineral deposits, and even snow melt from the glaciers in the Pyrenees were shipped all over the Mediterranean and prized by the wealthy in the Middle East more than a thousand years ago. Spain is a literal tapestry of all the cultures who have come and gone over the last 3000 years.

In the US, we think of the Spanish people as dark haired and mocha skinned. But when you walk the streets of any city in Spain you see that’s a stereo-type easily disproved. People here look like those in the US, France or Germany or even Ireland. And speaking of Ireland – when I was in Galicia, the most NW region in Spain – I saw signs of the Celts everywhere. I was told there was a strong connection between Gallegos and those of the Emerald Isles. I had just assumed that Irish mariners had landed on the Galecian shores and settled that area. But nothing could be further from the truth.

Celts came from central Europe in what is now Northern France, Belgium and Germany over the Pyrenees. Their settlements reached far to the south before being pushed back by the Romans and eventually the Visigoths. But it was after that period that they got in boats and ventured to Ireland and Great Britian. So it was the Celts going from Galicia not the other way around. And they brought the bagpipes with them. Yes, the bagpipes, that are the national instrument of Galicia, Scotland and Ireland, didn’t originate from any of those places. It came from Africa where the goat herders used flutes and bags of air made of goat skins to make music. So it’s no wonder I have North African, Iberian and German DNA, if I have Irish DNA. Because the Celts brought it with them when they went from Spain to Ireland.

During this lecture series, covering 10,000 years of history, it started to become clear that you couldn’t tell the history of Spain and not tell the history of the rest of Europe and North Africa and the Middle East. The story even reaches all the way to India and the Americas. And all along the way, there were wars. The conquerors and the conquered. New inventions and technology. New religions and old ones lost to the sands of time. Borders were ever changing and it became hard to keep up with who was in charge of one region or another. Especially in El Anduluz (Spain south of Galica, Asturias, and the Basque Country).

And it got me thinking. Today, we see the rise of Nationalism going on all over Europe and in the US. I hear people from Britian say ‘Britian should be for the British’ and I watch some of the violence against immigrants in Eastern Europe on tv. In the US, the jailing of those crossing the Mexican border trying to escape violence in their own countries leaves me heart broken, as they are treated as sub-human. But if any of those advocating for these ‘nationalist ideals’ took the course I took, they would understand that there is no such thing as pure national identity. If they knew history, they’d know there never really has been. It’s a modern marketing construct with ever moving historical borders. And our DNA is proof.

Riding through Strasbourg, France last year – sure, its France today. But it’s flip flopped so many times that the people there speak their own unique language, a blend of both French and German. This is much like Spain with its regional languages and traditions, whose differences are generally celebrated nowadays rather than viewed with suspicion.

They say America was the ‘Great Experiment’, and there is very real fear that with what’s going on today politically, it’s been irreparably damaged so as never to recover. But after completing this Spanish history course, I think the Greatest Experiment is the European Union (EU). Bringing together so many cultures and sub-cultures. People who had a long history of fighting each other, and a string of wars stretching back millennia. With differing languages and values. But then they figured out they were stronger together. That they had more in common than their differences of the past. And they’re actually DNA cousins, after all. Is it perfect? No, but I pray it survives the current climate.

I think of it in these terms. Its like a person who has been ill. They’ve taken medicine for their illness for a long time and they feel better. So much so that they fool themselves into believing they’re not ill anymore and can stop taking their medication. So they do stop, and they fall ill again, much to their surprise.

This is how we are with history. We know terrible things happened. Wars, genocide, oppression and famine. But it’s been a couple of generations since so many of those things happened in Europe. And in the US, we haven’t fought a war on our own soil since the Civil War more than 150 years ago. It easy to believe things have always been how they are today – filled with relative prosperity and peace. But those things were hard won by people who are no longer here to tell us just how hard it really was. And our collective memory, and our attention span, is short. Like the patient, there is a cure for what ails us, and it’s peace and cooperation. Pretending the solution is the isolationism of the past will only bring disaster.

I was sad when the series of lectures was over. I’m a history geek to my very core. But listening to all that came before, it gave me hope for the future. Sometimes we have to take one step back before we can take a giant leap forward. You see it countless times throughout history. But I truly believe that in the end, we’ll realize that our futures, and those of our children, depend upon our ability to cooperate and to see each other as vital to that future and not an impediment to it. And I hope we do that before it’s too late.

7 thoughts on “The Spanish Melting Pot

  • You live in an amazing city, Valencia. This is a YouTube video of a flash mob performance in Valencia :).



  • Well deserved comeuppance, and thank you. Instead of “great nations”, I should have used “nuclear armed nations” of which there are nine, though I wouldn’t be surprised to see Iran eventually acquire them as well. World wars which involved Europe, Russia, China, the US and Japan, probably will never happen again, due to mutual assured destruction. No rational leader will start a war in which he/she themselves will die. I was using the term “brush fire” to contrast the smaller wars of today with the epic world wars. It is estimated that 40 million people died in WW1 and 70-85 million people died in WW2, for a total of 110 to 125 million people in those two wars. It however is a poor choice of words. I think the plague for the current world are genocides and proxy wars as you stated. For genocides, the only thing I have ever seen work is the intervention of larger powers. Usually a lot of people die before an intervention starts, as in Bosnia. Proxy wars are just callous and obscene. I do see a world better than it used to be. Europe ALWAYS had wars, up until the end of WW2. It wasn’t the world war that stopped the wars in Europe, it was the overarching threat of nuclear power that stopped them. I would like to see a successor to the UN be an umbrella organization that includes all the nations of humanity sitting under a common roof. I would like to believe that the world is slowly moving in the direction of greater and greater world peace. I would also like to see the US led by thoughtful adults. Actually, I think the world might be a better place if there were more women leaders.

    But K, I do not have the world experience that you do, nor the close up views of some of the real trouble spots in the world. Like you, I do not believe in “manifest destiny”. At all. I do think all humans are brothers and sisters. But we spent a million or more years in tribes where our ancestors mostly either killed or ran from anyone from another tribe. As civilizations arose only in the last 10,000 years, evolutionarily speaking, in an instant, we have put a thin veneer over our tribal instincts and have begun the long journey to being more civilized with each other. A journey I think the human race has just begun. Let’s see what the next 10,000 years brings.


  • Hi K,
    Great thoughts! We are all members of one of the most advanced species in our Galaxy. We should revel in that and stop squabbling with each other :). And our human race histories are just phenomenal, as you are enjoying! I think the reason wars between the great nations has stopped is because of nuclear bombs. The threat of mutual assured destruction, the MAD of our youth, is very very real, and has made war impossible. Hence we don’t do it any more. Excepting for little brush fire skirmishes here and there. But the great wars of history are pretty much, well, history. :). So the peoples of the world are now figuring out how to be “peaceful” with each other. Because there really is no other choice. But it seems we have a long way to go in figuring out this “peace” thing and getting it right.


    • I think I’ll have to disagree with the term ‘Great Nations’. That’s a value judgement I would never make and I’m not sure upon what you’re basing this term. I guess its a trigger for me, like the term ‘Manifest Destiny’ – where we European Americans wiped out Native American tribes because we believed we were somehow ordained to do so by God, to take their land. It’s all Bollocks. As to ‘MAD’ – well, that certainly has kept the US locked in a face off with other nuclear powers (of which there are only a handful). But instead of using nuclear weapons against each other, they all fight Proxy Wars on other people’s soil – mostly in places far from themselves where their populations won’t be directly impacted, except for seeing it on TV like a reality show. Sadly, the native populations of those other countries don’t have that luxury. But Europe didn’t evolve into the EU because they all had nukes – they barely had their own armies after WWII. They joined together economically and in many ways, politically, because they not only saw a potential benefit to their people, but because, after two devastating world wars on their soil, those ties could avert future conflict. They were stronger together. As to ‘Little brush fires’ I have to take umbrage with this phrase. That’s a strictly American point of view; where sitting comfortably in an easy chair ten thousand miles away from Proxy wars and genocides in places like Yemen (>100,000 dead from the war and it’s evil twins, Famine and Diseases, like Cholera) and Syria (more than half a million dead – with the same # forced to flee to Europe fomenting nationalist sentiments) can be switched off the TV or the channel changed. I don’t think a Syrian mother watching her child die in a chemical weapons attack would see the conflict as ‘A little brush fire’. She would see this term as obscene. Living in Valencia – boats filled with those fleeing conflict, starvation and displacement arrive at our port, and their desperate faces are heartbreaking. I would never characterize a war as a ‘great war’. To me – there could never be any such thing.


  • Well said. Why didn’t we learn more about European history in school? The only thing I remember is memorizing dates of wars. I love learning about the history of where I live. I used to question Milito’s mother about her life as a child and then a young widow with 3 children and no money because she lived through the civil war and the Franco years. It was a hard life. It helps me to understand the people around here, especially Milito. Anyway, I would go to a lecture about the history of bandaids if it was available around here.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s